The Journal

Pricing

Fixed fee vs monthly web design: the 5 year cost

A one off build costs £500 to £3,000+ up front. Monthly starts from £20 a month with nothing up front. Here's how the two compare over the years, and which suits you.

Gavin Fawcett
6 min readUpdated

There are two honest ways to pay for a business website. You can hand over one lump sum and own it, or you can pay a smaller amount every month and have it handled for you. Most of the fixed fee vs monthly web design debate is fought on feelings: one side says a subscription is a trap, the other says a big upfront bill is a barrier. Feelings are a poor way to spend money.

So let us do the arithmetic instead. Real figures, added up over real years, so you can see exactly where each model wins and where they meet. By the end you should know which one is cheaper for you, and why that depends almost entirely on one question you already know the answer to.

The two payment structures, stripped back

A fixed fee means you pay once and the site is yours. In the UK that one-off might be £500 to £2,000 with a freelancer, and £3,000 and up with an agency, though these are rough and general ranges. Whatever the figure, ongoing costs like hosting, security and updates are then your problem to arrange and pay for separately.

A monthly subscription spreads the cost and usually folds the ongoing work in. At Build 76 that means no setup fee, then from £20 a month covering hosting, security, updates, maintenance and small content changes. No minimum term, cancel anytime, and nothing's charged until your site is live.

Running the numbers year by year

Here's the monthly path, before VAT. From £20 a month, with no setup fee. Nothing else to add, because the ongoing work is already inside that figure.

Now the one-off path with a freelancer or agency. You pay a lump sum once, often somewhere from a couple of thousand pounds upward. After that the hosting, security and updates are your problem to arrange and pay for separately, and self-hosting is rarely free once you add a domain, a decent host and a plugin or two.

Line those up and a clear picture appears. The subscription is far cheaper to get live: from £20 a month against a lump sum of thousands. Put another way, you're trading a low, spread cost with the upkeep included for a big one-off that leaves the running costs on your plate afterwards.

In the early years the subscription is far cheaper to get live: from £20 a month against a lump sum of thousands.

Where fixed fee and monthly converge

Over five years the monthly path keeps everything included the whole way. A one-off build costs less in raw fees over a long enough hold, but only once you add on the hosting, security and upkeep it leaves you to sort yourself.

Over a long enough hold, a one-off build you own can work out cheaper in raw fees, as long as you keep paying for the hosting, security and upkeep it doesn't include. The trade is convenience and cash flow against ownership, and we walk through more of the workings in why we charge monthly.

Keep the same site long enough and owning it outright becomes the cheaper option.

So which model is better for you?

It comes down to how long you'll realistically keep the same site. If you expect to run this exact website for six years or more without a rebuild, a fixed fee is likely to cost you less in total, provided you're happy to arrange hosting, security and updates yourself or pay for them.

If you'd rather not think about any of that, or you want to be live quickly without a big upfront bill, the monthly model is better value for the years that matter most to a growing business. Websites also tend to get replaced sooner than people expect. Five years is a long time for a small business, and many owners rebuild before a one-off build ever pays back. Put honestly: monthly wins on cash flow and convenience, a fixed fee wins on the long, patient hold. You can see how our pricing works on our pricing page.

One more way to frame it. If a typical job earns you about £300 in profit, a single extra job covers a whole year of the monthly plan, not three a month. Against that, you should choose on how you want it handled, not on the pennies.

See it before you decide

Numbers on a page only go so far. The easier decision is made looking at your actual site. Order today and we'll design your new homepage as a real, working clickable prototype and send you a link within three working days. Nothing's charged until your site is live. You try it on your phone, compare it to what you have now, and only pay if you want to go ahead. If you don't, you walk away and owe nothing.

Whether you end up choosing a fixed fee or a monthly plan, seeing the finished thing first takes the guesswork out of the sum. Have a look at the website offer when you're ready, or the monthly model set out in full, and pick the payment structure that fits how long you plan to keep it.

Share